Coaching Is a Rhythm, Not a Rescue
Let's be honest about performance improvement plans. For most people, "PIP" doesn't mean "my company is investing in my growth." It means "start updating your résumé."
What you'll learn:
Why performance improvement plans earned their dreaded reputation, how most of them are really the bill coming due for a year of avoided conversations, and four moves to build a coaching rhythm that makes the formal plan rare — and never a surprise.
Somewhere along the way, the PIP became the paperwork we file when we've already decided someone's done — a formal record built to protect the organization more than develop the person. It's gotten pointed enough that Harvard Business Review recently ran a case study debating whether companies should abandon PIPs altogether. When the flagship management publication is openly asking whether a tool should be scrapped, it's worth paying attention.
But the document isn't the villain. A clear, shared plan to help someone improve is a good idea. The problem is almost never the plan. It's the year that came before it.
Think about how most PIPs actually happen. A small issue shows up. The manager notices — and decides not to say anything yet. Too busy, too awkward, don't want to make it a thing. The issue repeats. Still nothing. Months pass. The small, fixable moments pile up, uncorrected, until one day they've accumulated into a case. Then it all gets delivered at once, in a formal document, to a person who had no idea the ledger was even open.
That's not development. That's a bill coming due — and we're handing it to someone who never saw the invoice.
Gallup tells the same story from the other side: 74% of employees get a performance review once a year or less, and only 14% strongly agree those reviews inspire them to improve. When feedback only arrives in big, infrequent events, it doesn't help people grow. It ambushes them.
So the fix isn't a better PIP template. It's a different rhythm entirely. Coaching and correction belong in the ongoing flow of how we relate to our people — small, frequent, in the moment — not saved up and dumped once a year.
Here's the part we have to be honest about. The reason we skip the small conversation is usually fear. Fear of the discomfort. Fear of being disliked. Fear of getting it wrong. So we tell ourselves we're being kind by letting it slide. We're not. Avoidance isn't kindness — it's postponement, and the other person pays the interest later.
Real kindness is direct. "Be kind" has never meant "be nice." It means caring enough to contribute to someone's growth, even when it's uncomfortable. And whether that correction lands depends almost entirely on where it's coming from inside you. Correct from your Critic — the voice that needs to be right, that's keeping score — and the person feels judged. Correct from your Executive — the part genuinely invested in them — and the very same words feel like someone has their back. People read your posture before they process your sentence.
Four moves to make coaching a rhythm instead of a rescue:
1. Catch it small. Say something while it's still a two-minute nudge, not a saved-up list. The earlier the conversation, the lighter it is — for both of you.
2. Check your posture first. Before you speak, notice where it's coming from. Are you here to be right, or to help them get better? If it's the former, wait until it's the latter. They'll feel the difference beneath every word.
3. Build the rhythm. Make coaching ongoing and expected — frequent, informal, two-way. When feedback is a normal part of the relationship, it stops being a threat and becomes a gift.
4. If a formal plan is ever needed, make it continuous — never a surprise. On the rare occasion a written plan is warranted, it should read as the next chapter of a conversation you've already been having. Co-author it. Resource it. If the plan is the first time they're hearing about the problem, you've already failed them.
Do this, and the dreaded PIP mostly disappears — not because problems vanish, but because you handled them while they were still small, inside a relationship built on honesty instead of accumulation. The goal was never a better form to fire people with. It was to never let it get that far.
Coaching isn't a rescue you perform when it's almost too late. It's a rhythm you keep all year. Start this week — with one small conversation you'd normally have postponed.
Did you find this article valuable? Don't miss our weekly insights on transformational leadership and building exceptional cultures.
Subscribe to Elevate Your Culture - our Monday morning newsletter delivering actionable leadership strategies directly to your inbox.
Join leaders across industries who start their week with clarity, purpose, and practical tools to unlock potential in themselves and their teams.
No time for another newsletter? Follow us on LinkedIn for bite-sized leadership wisdom throughout the week.